PURLs

Is it DVT? Wells score and D-dimer may avert costly workup

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

TABLE
Wells score estimates probability of deep vein thrombosis
The elements of the Wells score should be ascertained in the usual evaluation of a patient with suspected DVT.

1 POINT EACH FOR:
Active cancer
Paralysis, paresis, recent plaster immobilization of lower limb
Recently bedridden for >3 days or major surgery in past 4 weeks
Localized tenderness along distribution of deep venous system
Entire leg swollen
Calf swelling >3 cm compared to asymptomatic leg
Pitting edema
Collateral superficial veins
–2 POINTS FOR:
Alternative diagnosis as likely or more likely than that of DV T
PROBABILITY:
High>3 points
Intermediate1 or 2 points
Low<0 points

What’s New?: This evidence is definitive

This PURL may be old news to you if you have been watching the evolution of DVT risk scoring and the role of D-dimer. This is one of those approaches for which the evidence grows over time and the adoption spreads slowly. We felt that the cumulative evidence, especially this decision analysis,1 clearly points to the most current Wells score and the D-dimer as the approach of choice for initial evaluation of suspected DVT. This more definitive evidence and the variability of practice both reported in the literature and described by our clinician reviewers led us to decide that this study is a priority update and a practice changer—even if it is a slow practice changer.

Caveats: One strategy doesn’t fit all

The authors stress that their results are most applicable to outpatients with a suspected first DVT.1

  • D-dimer levels can be elevated in pregnancy, myocardial infarction, cancer, trauma, and postsurgery. These recommendations do not apply to patients with any of these conditions, patients on anticoagulation therapy, intravenous drug abusers, or patients with recurrent DVT.
  • In practices where D-dimer testing is not feasible, ultrasound remains an effective approach to suspected DVT.

Challenges To Implementation: Haven’t memorized the Wells score? No problem

As simple as it seems to add up the Wells score, most of us are not likely to recall the scoring system unless we use it often enough to have memorized it. Lack of immediate access to scoring systems in the context of a hectic schedule is a barrier to adoption.

Fortunately, many handheld and Web-based electronic knowledge resources are available for easy retrieval of the Wells DVT score. Some will even dynamically calculate the score for you.

Ideally, scoring systems such as this need to be integrated into electronic health records for easy access at the point of patient care.

Which Wells score?

There are several other scoring systems for estimating DVT risk, but the Wells DVT score is the best studied. To add to the confusion, Wells and his colleagues have made continuous improvements over time, such that there are several versions of the Wells DVT score.

In a quick Google search, we found six versions in which either the criteria or the interpretation was different, not to mention multiple other systems. The one used in this meta-analysis1 and described in this PURL is the most recent, most accurate and best studied.

PURLs methodology

This study was selected and evaluated using the Family Physician Inquiries Network’s Priority Updates from the Research Literature Surveillance System (PURLs) methodology.

Pages

Copyright © 2007 The Family Physicians Inquiries Network.
All rights reserved.

Recommended Reading

Practical strategy for detecting and relieving cluster headaches
MDedge Family Medicine
For fibromyalgia, which treatments are the most effective?
MDedge Family Medicine
Chest pain, weakness, and elevated cardiac enzymes: How would you treat?
MDedge Family Medicine
Does psychiatric treatment help patients with intractable chronic pain?
MDedge Family Medicine
Left-sided back pain that won’t go away
MDedge Family Medicine
What is the best way to diagnose a suspected rotator cuff tear?
MDedge Family Medicine
Who should receive vertebroplasty?
MDedge Family Medicine
What is the prognostic value of stress echocardiography for patients with atypical chest pain?
MDedge Family Medicine
Nodulo-cystic eruption with musculoskeletal pain
MDedge Family Medicine
Calcaneal apophysitis: Simple diagnosis, simpler treatment
MDedge Family Medicine