Clinical Inquiries

Does surgery relieve the pain of a herniated disc?

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Surgery improves leg pain, not disability, more than conservative therapy
Another RCT also directly compared microdiscectomy to conservative treatment in 283 patients with confirmed LDH and symptoms lasting 6 to 12 weeks.7 The surgical group underwent microdiscectomy within 2 weeks of randomization. Pain and disability measurements, based on standardized scales, showed significant improvement in leg pain (P<.001) for the surgical group, but no significant difference in disability.

Patient perception of recovery on a Likert-type scale showed a median recovery time of 4 weeks for the surgical group and 12 weeks for the conservative therapy group. No significant differences in perceived degree of recovery were noted between the groups at 1 year; 95% of participants had a satisfactory recovery.

Again, significant crossover occurred: 11% of patients allocated to surgery recovered before surgery, and 39% of the conservative therapy group experienced worsening symptoms or intractable pain that led them to undergo microdiscectomy.

Open discectomy, microdiscectomy produce similar results
A Cochrane review of interventions for LDH included only the Weber2 and SPORT3 RCTs. The review also included 3 RCTs that compared open discectomy and microdiscectomy. These studies found no difference in pain relief or complications between the 2 interventions.8

Recommendations

The Institute for Clinical Systems Improvement guidelines for adult low back pain list cauda equina, progressive neurologic deficits, or uncontrolled pain as reasons for direct referral to a spine specialist.1 Patients can be treated conservatively for 6 weeks without imaging, unless other symptoms or concerns are present.

The guidelines recommend that patients with chronic sciatica (lasting >6 weeks) receive further imaging or referral to a specialist if the patient is a potential candidate for surgery.

Pages

Evidence-based answers from the Family Physicians Inquiries Network

Recommended Reading

What is the appropriate evaluation and treatment of children who are “toe walkers”?
MDedge Family Medicine
Nodulo-cystic eruption with musculoskeletal pain
MDedge Family Medicine
Arthroscopic surgery for knee osteoarthritis? Just say no
MDedge Family Medicine
Cochrane Musculoskeletal Group review: Acute gout
MDedge Family Medicine
Nursemaid’s elbow: Its diagnostic clues and preferred means of reduction
MDedge Family Medicine
Sequential bilateral hip deformities
MDedge Family Medicine
Annual zoledronic acid infusion lowers risk of fracture, death
MDedge Family Medicine
Bisphosphonate therapy: When not to monitor BMD
MDedge Family Medicine
Vertebroplasty for osteoporotic fracture? Think twice
MDedge Family Medicine
Help patients prevent repeat ankle injury
MDedge Family Medicine